When you’re stuck, when you don’t know how to proceed or progress, the main question to ask yourself is why you’re stuck. The answer is often far from obvious. The problem is that there often are many factors that have to come together for progress to occur, and if any of these are lacking, you will get stuck. And different people lack different things, and the same person can lack different things at different occasions, or at different places in the development.
And by stuck I mean on any level, anything from a very general… stuckiness, like not knowing how to become a better chess player (or writer, or whatever) to being stuck in a more specific situation, like a case of ‘writers block’.
It was only very recently I started out with electronic music (some two months ago), but I knew from a couple of short earlier attempts that I have problem with creating a complete songs. It’s easy enough to create 10 seconds of cool music, and then another ten seconds of cool music that doesn’t fit the first 10 seconds. And that’s a problem.
In my earlier attempts I really had no idea why, and I couldn’t progress. This time, however, knowing more about the conditions of progress, and having more experience in general (having thought much about similar issues in other areas, such as chess, writing and programming), I knew (or thought I knew, and I was correct) the answer right away.
I asked in a few forums, but I only got answers like “find a way to get inspiration”, “work with others”, “just create, don’t think so much about it” etc. None of those answers helps in the slightest, though I still got some interesting information (such as learning that it’s a pretty common problem).
Anyway, the primary answer is that I lacked (and still do, but less so) knowledge about the structure of songs (which you could guess from the title of the post…). Those of you who have read my earlier posts on writing know that I’m a sucker for structure. Not to follow blindly, but as a mental tree of knowledge to pick ideas from, and to describe (and remember) music in terms of.
The music I’m creating is a kind of progressive electronic music and it doesn’t fit any pop structure like “verse, chorus, verse” etc, so I’m not primarily talking about learning exact structures, but rather concepts pertaining to structure. Just applying concepts like “transition”, “flow”, “contrast”, “building block”, “development” and the like is very helpful when creating music och thinking out different parts.
It’s also helpful to have a more specific idea of what you want to create, to be able to study the structure of that kind of music (among other things). My first goal is to make music in the vein of Aphex Twins Selected Ambient Works 85-92. I choose that one because the songs are relatively simple but still very effective. Each song has its own unique structure, but I’m sure there are similarities on a more abstract level.
As soon as I had studied structure for a couple of weeks I easily created a longer song. It’s far from complete, but I have four minutes of it (not mixed or polished at all yet), and I could (and will) easily add another minute or two. Also, the structure is unique and “progressive”, so, again, I’m not after learning “rules” to follow blindly. I’m just after expanding my knowledge of possibilities, and then combining them in new and interesting ways.
Had I tried another method, like “trying to find things that inspire me”, I would have gotten nowhere.